Kim - Let me know if you try Bare Essentials. I've thought about trying it, but I have a feeling that it'll be generally the same as everything else except more money.
I'm definitely interested though! I'm somewhat similar to you with my eyes. I can't say that they're dark circles, but it's like they're constantly puffy underneith no matter how much sleep I get. It's a constant thing. I think it may just be me though...not anything to do with PCOS or any other such thing. I've tried some of the Mary Kay products that are supposed to reduce puffiness, but they don't do a thing.