I ended up going to Ohio Reproductive Medicine, and I saw Dr. Grosskinsky. I was very happy with the visit and how I was treated. The plan that he came up with sounds very promising.
I was able to call the office directly and just make an appointment without a referral.
Ohio Reproductive Medicine
4830 Knightsbridge Boulevard
Suite E
Columbus, OH 43214
614-451-2280
They have a great website, too:
http://www.ohiorepromed.com/
Good luck everyone!